Showing posts with label post-modern retail. Show all posts
Showing posts with label post-modern retail. Show all posts

Wednesday 11 March 2015

The Tesco-Schweppes Pricing Spat - really about ownership of the Consumer?

In my early days in marketing, I was always surprised that my UK colleagues agonised for hours re every shelf-price increase of a few pence, whilst my continental colleagues focused on back margin and hardly touched on shelf prices. The answer came in a negotiation session with a major French retailer when a reference to shelf-price impact was slapped down with ‘when we buy your product, the selling price is our business. Now tell me about the back margin’…

In this era of post-modern retail – think game-changing 2007 financial crisis, a new world of multiplicity, diversity, contingency, fragmentation and rupture which accepts that we now live in a state of perpetual incompleteness and the permanently unresolved – an era where the 4x4 consumer has morphed into a basket-carrying shopper searching out daily bargains, and consumer-ownership has become the issue.

In other words, Tesco – and later the other mults – are simply clearing the decks, simplifying the offering and taking control of the shelf, especially pricing.

In terms of the consumer, if ‘ownership’ is defined by extent of knowledge, then retailers combining Clubcard and scanning data to produce a shopper-profile that includes name, address, age, sex, family structure, income-level, state-of-health, recreations and travel, dietary habits, insurance, debt-profile and bank-balance, have to have a greater claim to ownership of the consumer than a marketer knowing that the consumer is probably grey-haired and living alone on the outskirts of Oxford, two children having left home… This was a battle for ownership that was lost way before 2008.

In other words, we now have to accept that a retailer in the midst of a 30% product cull, and in the rifle-sights of the SFO and GCA, is not going to take any prisoners, much less tolerate any interference re how they market to ‘their’ consumer-shopper...

In reality, however, the consumer is now ‘ownerless’, savvy, willing and able to shop around, and is determined to accept nothing less than demonstrable value for money…

Welcome to the new world of post-modern retail…