Key Rivals Matching Asda In Price War

While Asda has stated its aim to establish a 5%-10% price gap over its full-range rivals, new data suggests Tesco and Sainsbury’s are making it difficult for the struggling retailer to make progress with its strategy to win back shoppers.

The latest price comparison survey by trade magazine The Grocer, which looks at a basket of 33 everyday items, saw Tesco beat Asda by 54p in last week’s analysis.

Amid recent signs that food inflation is starting to ease, the cost of the selection of goods at Tesco and Sainsbury’s was 11% less month-on-month, while Asda’s was down 0.3% month-on-month

The Grocer noted that Tesco’s win was powered by several deep discounts, with its £81.04 basket featuring 11 price cuts.

Asda’s £81.58 basket offered the lowest price on 13 lines, with its EDLP strategy evident in several areas where it was cheapest without promotions.

Tesco’s selection was 1.4% less than Sainsbury’s (£82.18) and 6.1% cheaper than Morrisons (£86.31), where prices rose by 4.6% month-on-month, the highest of all retailers.

Last month, Asda trumpeted that it was cutting the cost of over 1,000 products as part of its drive to improve its price competitiveness. The retailer noted that the price cuts were intended to help ease the financial pressures currently being faced by many households as they head into the most expensive time of year.

The reductions were in addition to nearly 3,500 Rollback deals currently available in its stores.

Back in March, Asda signalled that it was willing to take a material hit to its profits in a bid to win back shoppers. However, price cuts since then have failed to halt its slide in market share, with Tesco and Sainsbury’s maintaining their momentum and the discounter’s making further gains.

Last month, Asda told suppliers at its annual conference in Leeds that it was launching a reset of its product offer “bay by bay” as it looks to accelerate its turnaround plan, which its Chairman, Allan Leighton, said was “30% complete”.

NamNews Implications:

• The key to price war success is perhaps not so much how shelf prices compare…
• …but how deep a retail rival can afford to go...
• ...and for how long...
• i.e. Tesco & Sainsburys, Aldi & Lidl may be in a better financial position than Asda & Morrisons…